Papa's Pizza

Discover delicious, generous portions at Papa's Pizza in Montague, MI. Enjoy deep dish pizza, Italian bread, subs, taco pizza, Mama Whoppa, and more in a family-owned atmosphere. Call +1 231-893-2755 for your favorite pizza today!

Welcome to Papa's Pizza

Signature Dining Experience

Papa's Pizza
Papa's Pizza
Papa's Pizza
Papa's Pizza

At Papa's Pizza, locals and visitors alike discover the heart of Montague's culinary scene. Located at 8812 Water St, this family-owned gem serves up an impressive selection of pizzas that satisfy every craving. From the cheesy deep dish pizza to the fulfilling Mama Whoppa sub, there’s something for everyone. With a menu boasting 30 mouthwatering items, Papa’s Pizza charms with generous portions that keep community members coming back for more.

Looking for a satisfying meal? This family-friendly spot provides a warm, inviting atmosphere along with a commitment to quality ingredients and friendly service. It’s more than just a restaurant; it's a place where families gather, friends connect, and everyone feels right at home.

Location & Contact

Address

8812 Water St, Montague, MI 49437, United States

Phone

+1 231-893-2755

Social Media

About

Papa's Pizza
Papa's Pizza
Papa's Pizza
Papa's Pizza

Papa's Pizza represents the spirit of Montague, MI. This neighborhood pizzeria captures the essence of comfort food with its extensive menu offerings. Patrons can explore five varieties of pizzas, including Super, Deluxe, and the beloved Taco pizza. Each pizza is crafted with fresh ingredients and a robust sauce, resulting in flavor that keeps customers returning time after time. Families enjoy the friendly atmosphere, while visitors appreciate the welcoming service that makes every meal a memorable experience.

Sub lovers will also find delight in the selection. The Papa Whoppa and Mama Whoppa subs consistently receive rave reviews for their large, flavorful fillings. These sandwiches, paired with a side of garlic bread or breadsticks, provide a fulfilling meal that’s easy on the wallet. For anyone looking for something different, the South of the Border section offers great options like Chips & Cheese and Taco Salads, all bursting with flavor and made to order.

With an average price of $10 per meal, Papa's Pizza excels in delivering value without compromising taste.

The owners understand the importance of community support—interacting with customers and participating in local events shows their commitment to Montague. Whether there’s a Friday night game or a community event, this local hotspot always joins in. Papa’s Pizza stands as a pillar of Montague, providing delicious food with a side of community spirit.

Work Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • TuesdayClosed
  • Wednesday4-9 PM
  • Thursday4-9 PM
  • Friday4-9 PM
  • Saturday4-9 PM

Papa's Pizza shines with a diverse menu that caters to all tastes. Whether you crave a hearty Meat Lovers pizza or prefer something lighter like a Veggie option, the restaurant has it covered. Sandwich lovers can delight in a variety of hot subs, including the audience-favorite Hawaiian and the spicy Taco Sub. For those looking to switch it up, the South of the Border section features delightful options like wet burritos and taco salads. With an average price of just $10, diners get great value for generous portions.

The family-owned business prides itself on quality and consistency, ensuring that every meal is as delicious as the last. Plus, the vibrant decor reflects Montague's community spirit—local artwork adorns the walls, providing a cozy, hometown feel.

Papa's Pizza

The exterior of Papa's Pizza is inviting, featuring bright signage that reflects the warmth inside. Located along Water St, this pizzeria fits seamlessly into the Montague landscape, drawing in both locals and visitors. The outdoor seating option allows patrons to enjoy warm Michigan evenings while savoring their meals. The laid-back atmosphere creates a perfect spot for families and friends to gather, making dining out a relaxing experience. Nearby parks and scenic views of the area enrichment the vibe, cultivating a genuine connection to the Montague community. Walking by this charming spot often tempts passersby to stop in and enjoy a slice or two.

Customer Reviews

This place has the most freaking amazing deep dish pizza I've ever eaten in my life. It has the perfect meld of flavors. I think we had one piece left and we bought two pizzas that evening... Papa's mostly advertises their thin crust and that's amazing but the deep dish is where it's at. I honestly cannot recommend it enough

A
Anthony S.

In my unrelenting quest to find the most exquisite pizza ever created, I discovered Papa's Pizza in Montague, MI. Arriving at this pizzeria felt like coming home with timeless decor, family games, and an ever-present charm. We ordered a smorgasbord of delectable treats. Starting with the Papa Whoppa, a sub with all the meats, it was especially wonderful thanks to their unique sauce, and the sandwich was perfectly toasted. The Super Pizza arrived next thanks to Papa Pizza's unparalleled service. This pizza was beyond fantastic. The soft, thinner crust was wonderful, but the sauce with all toppings was the icing on this extra tasty pie. Waiting only a short time later, the Deluxe Cheese Deep Dish was delivered to our table. This pie was simply incredible. The star of the show was the molten cheese coupled with the tasty spices on top. Last but certainly not least, we had the Italian Bread, which when paired with their pizza sauce, was absolutely fantastic. Our experience was marvelous thanks to the entire Papa Pizza Crew.

S
Stephen S.

We just left and i ran to give a review! The people running it amazing, the food amazing! Id advise ordering ahead if you get deep dish pizza (do it!) and definitely eat in! Oh and try the lettuce sauce.

K
Kerry S.

Very friendly staff. Awesome customer service! The pizza is absolutely fabulous. Tried the chicken, bacon ranch Sicilian style. Also tried the wet burrito. The food was top notch!

M
Melissa H.

Thanks for being so accommodating as we arrived in town kind of late, but we got the last pizza of the day. A delicious deep dish and some bread, and made fast! Thanks for making our food even though you barely had time before close. Great service! 10/10 highly recommend

S
S T.

This was our first time here and it was October 22nd. It was decorated yet had a very relaxed atmosphere. The food was delicious and unlike most Pizza places the pizza was not greasy. It was also freshly made. I would definitely recommend. We got 2 Pizzas, a cheese and a pepperoni.

K
Kali S.